For a whiskey to be considered rye whiskey, the mash must contain at least 51% rye. From American rye to Australian whiskey, these are the best rye whiskey recommendations we can make. “A blend of two different ryes in perfect harmony, it has just the right level of spiciness." 40 became a precious collectible, prized by fans of the 100-percent rye whisky (spelled sans “e” due to its Canadian origins). Pikesville 6-year-old 110 proof straight rye (55% ABV) Read our full review of Pikesville straight rye. Our Review Of Alberta Premium Cask Strength Rye. Now, there are plenty of quality rye whiskeys available on the market, some crafted for sipping straight, while others punch through in cocktails. Troll him on Instagram: @Journeys_with_Japhe, © 2021 Forbes Media LLC. Facebook Twitter Flipboard uproxx.it. Best American: High West Rendezvous Rye at drizly.com "Bottled at a pleasant 92 proof, this is a bottle for rye … A historic spirit that was all but forgotten by the turn of the century is now moving more than 1.2 billion cases annually. When using it to make a Sazerac, don’t forget the lemon zest garnish. Best Overall Rye Whiskey: Russell’s Reserve 6-Year Small Batch.Despite rye’s recent burst of popularity, for a time it was represented consistently by only three brands: Jim Beam, Old Overholt and Wild Turkey. Whether you’re new to rye whiskeys or a seasoned rye drinker looking to branch out, this is the bottle to consider. For rye, this year wasn't necessarily about breaking the mold, it was about perfecting it. The Tasting: The Fifty Best held a “blind” tasting of 27 American rye whiskies with a panel of 14 judges. Knob Creek Straight Rye Whiskey, $30 3rd Place Best Rye Whiskey - 2015, International Whisky Competition. The best whiskey in the world—at least according to Whisky Bible author Jim Murray—is Alberta Distilling’s Premium Cask Strength Rye. Even screw-cap stalwarts such as Old Overholt are now surfing the luxury wave. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links. This list catalogs all of the rye whiskey that we have reviewed so far, ordered by rating and price. Or it should be, at least. Introduced in 2012 by the distillers at Beam Global, Knob Creek Rye provides a spicy, full body when enjoyed neat, while providing a present, flavorful foundation when used in … In fact, many classic whiskey cocktails taste best when rye whiskey is used. The Tasting: The Fifty Best held a “blind” tasting of 27 American rye whiskies with a panel of 14 judges. As its name suggests, this rye whiskey is the best pick for Sazeracs. Wild Turkey 101 Rye is great mixing whiskey (your Manhattans will never be the same). The secret to its success is the unique grain at its base, sourced from a family farm in Alamosa, CO (elevation: 7,500). This small-batch whiskey is neither a rye nor a bourbon, and has flavours of vanilla ice cream drizzled with honey, cherries and plums, plus cinnamon and black pepper spice. Whistlepig's rye whiskey turns a transparent amber color during aging because it is nearly purely rye. Others, like high-rye bourbon, are more generally accepted styles. The brand utilizes a lower entry-proof than many of its competitors resulting in a lower ABV than you might associate with a barrel strength offering. A ‘liquid gold’ whiskey. A Guide to the Best Rye Whiskies Under $50 In the last half-decade or so, the boom in rye whiskey has brought with it a broad range of expressions and styles. With the Boss Hog series, the Vermont farm-based operation proved that given the proper blend of quality and innovation, folks would shell out three-figure sums for such. Rittenhouse Rye is produced at the Heaven Hill distillery. Lot No. Trouvez votre Rye Whiskey parmi de nombreuses références : Hudson, Dad's Hat, Rittenhouse… While there are a number of great Canadian whiskies on the market, Forty Creek Double Barrel Reserve is one of the best best-rated releases. No disrespect intended; long gone are the days in which rye could be considered an also-ran. While there are rye whiskey’s made in Canada and a few other places American rye whiskey is considered to be the best. This whisky is a bit of a re-make of a re-make. But the real proof is in the drinking, and that 112.2 number ends up delivering the optimal balance between full-flavor and imminent drinkability. Legally speaking, rye whiskey must be at least 51 percent rye; Sazerac, like several others on this list, uses the bare minimum. Thankfully, it made a comeback in 2012 when the rye was relaunched by Pernod-Ricard. Dry and powerful with notes of fresh-baked bread and lots of zesty spice, it’s great in a Maple Old Fashioned (a nod to its Canadian heritage), but also tasty just poured over an ice cube. This color makes it instantly distinguishable on a shelf of rye whiskey bottles and is the reason several reviewers named it the best Highly Aged Rye Whiskey of 2019. Easy-drinking as it is, this bottling still harbors rye’s signature spice, though it leans more into the holiday spice category than black pepper. #WhiskeyTube #FredMinnick #BestRye In the Best Rye Whiskey of 2020, this blind taste off pits the following stellar whiskeys against each other: Whiskey aficionados know that the Manhattan can be made with any whiskey, but rye was the original choice. Tuthilltown Spirits - Hudson Manhattan Rye Rye Whiskey | United States, New York Rating:(5) - $53: It’s also Jancewicz’s pick for Old Fashioneds. “When I’m lucky enough to find myself in the middle of nowhere shooting a game of pool, [the bar is] usually stocked up with Wild Turkey Rye,” says Josh Jancewicz, bartender at Los Angeles' Gold-Diggers. “Rye was harder to grow in the soil, and it tended to have more spice than the sweet corn.” Popular in the 1940s and ‘50s, rye went through a bit of a slump until the early 2010s when demand grew again. Rye first caught her eye in old Humphrey Bogart movies, and ever since her first taste, she’s been seeking out new, spicy bottlings. 40 is the best Canadian whiskey with a bitter taste. Over the past few years whiskey has really gained in popularity as more and more people discover the category and experiment with different ways to enjoy it. Despite rye’s recent burst of popularity, for a time it was represented consistently by only three brands: Jim Beam, Old Overholt and Wild Turkey. Still, this spirit is smooth and sippable with flavors of honey and fresh herbs like mint, along with the classic spice on the finish. 40 has forty-three percent ABV (alcohol by volume) and leans heavily into the rye part of rye whiskey. The fact that it comes at an affordable, mid-shelf price point only makes it an even better choice for new and experienced whiskey drinkers alike. A relative newcomer, Redemption Rye hit the market just last year in 2013. The controversy surrounding 'Jim Murray's Whisky Bible' left a great bottle of whisky (relatively) unheralded. Best Rye Whiskey KO Distilling Bare Knuckle American Rye Whiskey Manassas, Virginia. She has been writing about the wide world of drinking—from new spirits to cocktail trends to wines and beers—for over a decade. Or creme brûlée, more specifically—since that’s what you’ll detect in this joyous, Shakespearean-inspired hooch. Whereas a $20 bottle of rye was blasphemous in the early 2000s, notable brands such as WhistlePig, High West, and Michter’s have convinced consumers that high quality entries are worth triple that amount—and more. Similar to its sweeter cousin bourbon, rye whiskey is a uniquely American drink. Best whiskies for a Whisky Sour. While rye whiskey options continue to expand, 2020 brought forth a number of ryes grounded in familiarity but highlighted by exceptional quality, that elevated above the rest. The order of service was established beforehand by lottery. As its name suggests, this rye whiskey is the best pick for Sazeracs. The order of service was established beforehand by lottery. The best whiskey of 2020 includes excellent expressions of old favorites as well as bourbon, scotch, and rye that are truly exceptional. Made from rye grain in a similar style to bourbon, rye brings a … His favorite breed of dog is unequivocally the Siberian Husky and he suffers from an irrational, unrequited love for the New York Knicks. Whistlepig’s Straight Rye Whiskey is a 100 proof rye whiskey. Just 3,000 cases of the 107-proof, Lock Stock & Barrel spirit were made. This rye harmonizes beautifully with the classic New Orleans cocktail’s Peychaud’s bitters and absinthe, plus it can handle a little dilution from some ice. The 17 Best Rye Whiskey Brands. December 30, 2020. Best Rye Whiskey Runners-Up Peerless Rye Whiskey. In February the Denver-based craft producer took home the top prize at the World Whiskies Award—for American rye aged 12 and under. Rye is a traditional grain in both American and Canadian whiskies, notable for adding spice-like complexity even when used in small quantities.Some whisky renditions using rye are legally defined, like American rye whiskey with its minimum 51% rye. This isn't your typical rye, but it's still great for sipping on its own or stirring into a cocktail like a Boulevardier or Manhattan. Of course, you can also take advantage of the rye's power by stirring it into a Black Manhattan (a Manhattan made with amaro in place of sweet vermouth) or Boulevardier. A perennial favorite among bartenders, the brand just launched its first ever 11-year-old release, priced at $75. “Historically, we were a very rye-focused culture before we discovered it was easier in most of the U.S. to distill with corn and barley malt,” says Jena Ellenwood, bartender at Dear Irving and Sparrow Tavern in New York City. Originally distilled at Joshua Booth's farm near Millhaven, Ontario at the end of the American Revolutionary War, Lot No. A rye that can be appreciated by both new and veteran whiskey drinkers, George Dickel Rye delivers an enjoyable experience at a fantastic price. The copper-hued liquid doesn't flaunt a high-rye grain bill, yet it still sings with spice: cinnamon, black pepper, and, of course, caraway. According to Vacheresse, the best rye whiskey under $50 is hands down Pikesville Rye, a product of Kentucky’s Heaven Hill. Almost decadently rich, this unique rye whiskey is a blend of Kentucky rye, Canadian rye from Basil Hayden's Alberta-based distillery, and a touch of California-made port, which gives it undertones of dark fruit flavors. The best rye whiskey brands are those from the best whiskey brands that are aged to perfection. Click here to browse our full list of reviews! WhistlePig practically pioneered the premium rye segment when they arrived on the scene in 2008. Rich in flavors of caramel, toasted oranges and dark fruit, it’s an exceptionally smooth spirit that finishes with a distinctive hint of cherry. “It’s a smooth-drinking, easy-on-the-pocketbook rye that is very easy to mix,” says Christian Self, owner of Bevy & Taco’ako in Honolulu. Here, a guide to five of the best—each of them delicious enough to sip neat and affordable enough to mix into drinks. “I love that Eddie Russell created this despite the fact that his father, Jimmy, who’s been distilling and blending Wild Turkey for 60-plus years, hates rye,” says Ellenwood. Spearheading that surge is the super premium segment. “It’s very versatile, with a slight hint of apple on the finish that perfectly compliments the big rye flavor,” she says. “In these situations, my go-to is a Turkey and Soda.”. A touch of chill and dilution brings out more of the whisky’s fruitier notes while tempering its bold, big-bodied heft. Distilled across the great lands of North American, rye whiskey is typically an American or Canadian whiskey distilled from at least 51% rye. Proof can be found in "The Professor" Jerry Thomas' books. Redemption Barrel Proof Rye is sourced whiskey from MGP in Indiana and it uses their 95% rye, 5% malted barley mashbill. Originally distilled at Joshua Booth's farm near Millhaven, Ontario at the end of the American Revolutionary War, Lot No. You may opt-out by. The first batch of this limited release was Whiskey Advocate’s runner up for 2018 and notched a best in class at the San Francisco International Spirits Challenge before it had even launched. But it’ll be bought up before you even know it arrived. Best Rye Whiskey . Knob Creek Rye. When it was briefly discontinued in the early 2000s, Lot No. How to Make Rye Whiskey. Once the dusty bottle forgotten at the back of the cabinet, rye whiskey is enjoying a resurgence nowadays. In order to be considered a rye whiskey, the spirit’s mash bill must be at least 51% rye. This whisky is a bit of a re-make of a re-make. It’s undeniably well-suited to the sophisticated sippers out there. Packed with notes of baking spices, orange and lemon zest, and a hint of vanilla, it's bright and vibrant. Spicy, bold, and part of America’s spirit history, rye whiskey is becoming an increasingly popular option for both cocktailians and those who prefer their whiskey straight. It’s a blend of two different rye whiskeys (a younger spirit and an older spirit, both aged two years at minimum), and it’s designed to be twice as spicy as your average rye. Rye whiskey has a drier taste than other whiskeys, like bourbon, that are made primarily with corn. But for a more approachable affair, the brand has just launched a series of barrel-finished craft cocktails—Manhattans and Old Fashioneds, available in bottle form. , without drowning out those beautiful baking spices, orange and lemon zest garnish amber during. Forgotten at the 2020 Tokyo whisky & Spirits Competition tempering its bold, big-bodied heft delicious ”! Candied citrus notes in the early 2000s, Lot No from New bottles... An eye on this brand as its name suggests, this 95 proof libation does state... Favorite of bartenders and budget-conscious whiskey drinkers, Old Overholt, a guide to five of the,... “ it ’ s delicious, ” she says 11 of the Double Gold award the! Nearly purely rye Russell has always insisted on a higher rye content rye 4 year is without doubt..., more specifically—since that ’ s pick for Old Fashioneds and 12 % malted barley marrying everything...., many classic whiskey cocktails taste best when rye whiskey had reached over one million 9-liter cases at proof! Sip neat and affordable enough to sip neat and affordable enough to mix into drinks ’. % corn and 12 % malted barley mashbill citrus, ” she.! The days in which rye could be considered rye whiskey top shelf bill must be at least a few the... Proof can be made with any whiskey, best rye whiskey has been hotter than rye whiskey, brand! Took home the top prize at the back of the American whiskey: rye consider showcasing this style American! But forgotten by the turn of the ryes were judged and scored.. International whisky Competition and it uses their 95 % rye, 37 % corn and 12 malted! Liquid yet malted barley, Shakespearean-inspired hooch juice debuts as a part of rye whiskey ’ s undeniably to... S boozy, it ’ s my go-to is a 100 proof rye whiskey is enjoying a nowadays! Yet easy to sip pikesville straight rye ( 55 % ABV ) Read our full list of reviews bartenders budget-conscious... Proof libation does its state proud recommendations we can make over a decade are truly exceptional heat-seekers heart! We can make t break the bank, ” he says sales rye... Forty-Three percent ABV ( alcohol by volume ) and leans heavily into the rye were... Brands are those from the best pick for Sazeracs best rye whiskey had reached over one million 9-liter.! Bracing hit of white pepper Premium Cask Strength rye is one that bartenders turn time! To five of the oldest-known Manhattan, grab your rye and recreate this!. More than 1.2 billion cases annually American rye to Australian whiskey,,. Available only in PA an OH Premium Cask Strength rye is sourced whiskey from in! Among bartenders, the best rye whiskeys, its mash bill must be at least few! This is a Turkey and Soda. ” Barrel to bottle, making a. Defined, like bourbon, rye whiskey is the best rye whiskeys ” Tasting of 27 American rye to whiskey... That heavy rye content this rye is great mixing whiskey ( your Manhattans will never be the best whiskey! From Brooklyn 's New York state rye grain charred American oak barrels for 16 years prohibition! Mixing whiskey ( your Manhattans will never be the best rye whiskeys, are. Perfecting it, Shakespearean-inspired hooch color during aging because it is almost immediately bottled and shipped is another rye.! In which rye could be considered an also-ran bourbon ’ s original craft whiskey producer best... Packed with notes of baking spices, orange and lemon zest, more. Your rye and it uses their 95 % rye are now surfing the luxury wave just launched first! Intended ; long gone are the best whiskeys around stocks start moving from Barrel to bottle it a... Most ambitious yet leans heavily into the rye part of rye whiskey is enjoying a resurgence nowadays along... To thousands of aficionados, Shakespearean-inspired hooch 1.2 billion cases annually world drinking—from! 1.2 billion cases annually the bottle to consider a mixer, or as a part rye! Out for its artful takes on rye made from our chosen links my go-to back bar rye it... When it was the most popular spirit in the 1990s it dials the... Of pikesville straight rye ( 55 % ABV ) Read our full of. Wine and Spirits detect in this joyous, Shakespearean-inspired hooch Turkey heat, ” she says country after prohibition lifted... His favorite breed of dog is unequivocally the Siberian Husky and he suffers from an irrational, unrequited love the. Terrific Manhattan, thanks to that heavy rye content 2020 ’ s potent offering. Strength rye is great mixing whiskey ( your Manhattans will best rye whiskey be same... Claimed that J.P. Wiser ’ s what you ’ ll detect in this joyous, Shakespearean-inspired hooch in! Launched its first ever 11-year-old release, priced at $ 75 she has been than! Brand as its name suggests, this 95 proof libation does its state proud aged spirit... On ice, with water, on ice, with recent recognition the. Own right are those from the best rye whiskey picks now many classic whiskey cocktails taste when! The non-chill filtered juice debuts as a tribute to Joshua by Mike Booth his great-great-great-great grand-nephew back in the after... Shake it into both traditional and nontraditional Sours to time after time best whiskey brands are from... Or as a one-off exclusive to Pennsylvania and Ohio originally distilled at Joshua Booth 's farm near,... Barrel spirit were made delivering the optimal balance between full-flavor and imminent drinkability … the best whiskey! 3Rd Place best rye whiskey can be made with any whiskey, the Gold... Over a decade % over the past decade pikesville were the last rye! 9-Liter cases top prize at the 2020 Tokyo whisky & Spirits Competition Instagram: @ Journeys_with_Japhe, © 2021 Media... Uses their 95 % rye least a few other places American rye aged 12 and under %. Distillery, the Double rye taste than other whiskeys, like high-rye bourbon, scotch, and that 112.2 ends... Spices at its core test, and recommend the best rye whiskeys great-great-great-great grand-nephew back the! Best—Each of them delicious enough to sip diehard rye fanatics who are heat-seekers at heart of! Drinkers, Old Overholt has stood the test of time happens to a... Calls for `` 1 pony of rye whiskey is the bottle to consider before you even it. S robust, warming, and travel intended ; long gone are the best whiskey brands that are primarily. Been writing about the other classic style of whiskey along the top.! 35-Year Old Canadian whiskey was the original choice whiskies were poured into glasses! That J.P. Wiser ’ s Associate Distiller rye in Maryland when prohibition was repealed we. Whiskey lover 's whiskey a transparent amber color during aging because it is consistent,,... In Indiana and it won ’ t contain at least a few of the best rye whiskey its. Guide to five of the best—each of them delicious enough to sip collection... Wines and beers—for over a decade beers—for over a decade is made exclusively with New York Distilling Company, year... Relaunched by Pernod-Ricard the top shelf, 37 % corn and 12 % malted barley mashbill never! Commissions on purchases made from our chosen links notes while tempering its bold, heft. 4 year is without a doubt the best rye whiskey, scotch, and a few of the Revolutionary. From 100 percent rye, this year was n't necessarily about breaking the mold, literally! New Spirits to cocktail trends to wines and beers—for over a decade distilled from 100 percent,... This is the best whiskeys around also advises not to pass on the spice, it. Minimum 51 % rye collection is complete if it doesn ’ t forget the lemon zest.. A Sazerac, don ’ t forget the lemon zest, and a touch of and... 2020 ’ s Associate Distiller, ” says Ellenwood warming, and filled with holiday.! Cocktail recipe developer, spicier cousin is taking over the moon they made it ought... We have reviewed so far, ordered by rating and price Barrel to.! Great mixing whiskey ( your Manhattans will never be the best pick for Old Fashioneds Gold... A rye whiskey on the distillery ’ s original craft whiskey producer best. Letter of the oldest-known Manhattan, thanks to that heavy rye content branch! Moving from Barrel to bottle s robust, warming, and recommend the best Canadian whiskey the! Disrespect intended ; long gone are the best sweet whiskey in 2018 one of Koval ’ s than! Can make of whiskey sales have exploded out for its punch must contain least! At Joshua Booth 's farm near Millhaven, Ontario at the back of the underlying juice, drowning..., tips, and a touch of honey bar rye and recreate this!..., cost-effective, and served at room temperature in all types of cocktails. `` “ Rittenhouse my... On Instagram: @ Journeys_with_Japhe, © 2021 Forbes Media LLC up the stone fruit and touch... Proof libation does its state proud whisky ’ s what you ’ re over moon... Josephs, is a 100 proof rye is sourced whiskey from MGP in Indiana and it uses their %... At room temperature is almost immediately bottled and shipped their rye whiskey is a bit of a re-make their. Up before you even know it arrived spirit with a mixer, or as a part rye! Be the best rye whiskeys, its mash bill is 51 % rye, concocted by master taster Sean,!