are architectural shingles easier to install

– Lisa. Wayne, Just how many roof have you done? The cost of your shingle roof will depend on many factors, including roof size, if you need tear out your old roof, labor costs and … I prefer to select a shingle based on the roofers experience. Architectural shingles have been laminated to make them thicker. Typically, the cost of architectural shingles is only about 20% more than the traditional 3 tab shingles. Although the difference between three-tab and architectural shingles seems superficial, roofers consider the latter a more high-end roofing product. Yeh, it’s true. Safety ropes and harnesses are … Architectural shingles: 59%. But, like with the cedar shake roof, it requires dedicated maintenance for it to last that long. I am getting ready to re-roof with a complete tear-off. Replacing and Installing Architectural Shingles. Architectural shingles (3D) last longer but may not be an appropriate choice for shallow-pitch roofs. Architectural shingles have a three-dimensional look and a forty year warranty. Here’s why: So is cheaper better? Quality roofing nails need to be used to fasten the shingles and to install the roofing underlayment for waterproofing. What were Americans talked into that they don’t need? Roofing Stretcher, I think that the bundles of shingles are about the same weight, whether 3-tab or Dimensional. The roofing is traditional 3 tab. This was on a 100 square job. Actually, there are many places on earth, like in the northern states, where the temperatures are always low and still, the roofs are perfectly installed all the time. That's normal. There are less tabs/flaps to catch wind. Typically architectural shingles weight almost 50% more than the standard 3 tab shingles. Handle the shingles with care and caution. If you install your architectural roof shingles wrong, then you may find that you have to rip them all out and start again. When shopping for shingles, you may be swayed by the low cost of 3-tab shingles. Stay on topic. DeeDee. You don`t need to hire the services of any professional company to get these installed if you know proper material required and steps to follow. When you’re interested in architectural shingles installation in Kingwood, TX count on Mdw Roofing and Remodeling LLC and call us today at (832) 766-9994! Architectural shingles are a very popular shingle type that consists of two shingle strips that have been laminated together, which makes them thicker and more durable than standard shingles. I recently had a lot of wind damage to my roof from a storm and chose to replace my 3-tab shingles with architectural shingles. NOTE: 1) the house was built in central N.C., in 1992. PABCO Premier® Whether your home is new construction, or you are looking to upgrade your existing roof, PABCO Premier ® provides dependable protection for your home. I have a question about whether 3 tab shingles are actually the same or different than what someone is describing to me as “single tab” shingles? Measure your roof so you can be sure you buy the right amount of shingles. Three-tab shingles are cheaper upfront, but over the course of your roof’s lifetime, architectural shingles can cost less. We’re still getting quotes but our options so far are to repair with similar looking 3 tab, or replace the entire roof with arch. It’s often best to compare architectural shingles and three-tab shingles to determine which style is best suited to your home. Both have great warranties from companies. As for my roofer, he is a great roofer, has a great crew. Both want the same money. The main reason I chose to go this route was due to the wind resistance. Check out http://www.homeconstructionimprovement.com/asphalt-roof-shingle-warranty/ You probably already know that shingle warranties are not super great. Any suggestions? Anonymous. Have a couple of more questions for you, if it’s OK. 1) In your opinion do you think that the ‘Lifetime warranty’ that all the manufacturers are offering now, ends up not having much value down the line? I come across 3-tab and architectural shingles but nothing that just describes Single Tab as one contractor has mentioned. His employees are very efficient, and I guess work for small money, I don’t know what he pays them. Shingles have varying thicknesses and weights, depending on the material. Manufacturers make them using cedar … Architectural shingles typically have a minimum of 25 to 30 year warranties. Architectural Shingles. Landmark Pro Shingle Installations Waukesha WI. In the roofing industry, laminated shingles are further described as being “architectural” because they’re specially engineered to create architectural interest for the roof by means of the individual shingle’s contour, cut and dimensional thickness. Mary – There are some architectural shingles that have had serious issues (organic shingles from IKO is just one of the known culprits). I love the look, the weight, and the longer warranty. I mean if you made a mistake and stepped on the part of the metal that didn’t have a slat you might damage the metal itself. We had architectural installed 12 years ago, and a roofing bidder from Home Depot was at our home today bidding new gutters for our home, and said that our nails in our roof were lifting, and that our roof might last another 2-3 years! The main difference between architectural shingles and 3-tab shingles is the price. We install a lot of BOTH types and feel that, provided a quality installation, either type of shingle will serve nicely. If this guy is tearing off and reshingling for a $125.00-$130.00 a square, plus supplying the shingle the he is losing alot of money. Especially if your deductible is high. tHREE tAB SHINGLES–ARE GUARANTEED FOR 15–TO–25 YEARS..NICE NEAT STRAIGHT LINES. Enter keywords like, 'insulation' or 'kitchens' etc to find your topic. Of course you only want to walk occasionally on any roof because to much walking can cause problems for any roof. Easy installation; Let’s dive into these a little further. The price difference reflects this, with architectural shingles costing 20% to 40% percent more than three-tab shingles—a difference that can mean up to $1500 more for larger roofs. different types of roofs that exist, each with its own benefits and weaknesses. When to Replace Architectural Shingles You will pay a significant premium for architectural shingles. Why are they so popular? I too appreciate the questions and replies. They are inexpensive, come in a wide range of colors and profiles, are easy to install, and are suitable for a wide range of climates. Architectural shingles are now $84.99 a square, 3-tab are $62.00 per square. This conversation about 3 tabs and architectural shingles has been very helpful to me as I think I see a new roof in my future pretty soon. Begin a starter course by cutting off the tabs about two inches from the top of the shingle. Accurate measurements are essential for a successful installation. I don’t agree with the “they look like cedar shingles or shakes”. From my research it stated that architectural shingles weigh more than 50% more than the 3 tab. Also, your home owners insurance provider will give you a 20 percent discount on your yearly premium with architectural shingles. Architectural shingles cost a bit more to install at $1.50 to $5.50 per square foot or $150 to $550 per square. Metal shingles are stylish and available in many different colors. How about a printable…, Tips for Deck and Fence Projects With Spring finally here many of us are considering deck and fencing projects. Search for more articles here. I prefer rigid roof vents. the other one I don’t know anything about and he gives me only 2 years on labor. They come in more … I’ve been installing architectural shingles for years here in Nebraska. The fact of the matter is that although not an exact facsimile, dimensional shingles do look a LOT more like cedar shakes than a 3-tab shingle. This makes them both easier to install and means they are a less expensive upfront cost than architectural shingles. Architectural shingles or multi thickness asphalt shingles are other terms for laminated asphalt shingles. Of course not. past the … When installing shingles, I usually flip them over and cut them from the back side. 3 tabs are a thing of the past in my book. 3 cut tabs are not as sturdy as a solid shingle with laminated shake applied to it. Some have far more “reveal” than others. The move from traditional 3-tabs to architectural laminated shingles was mainly an aesthetic evolution. (can send a picture if you forward your email) The roofing salesman suggests either a 2-step modified roofing product, with a 10 year warranty, (2 squares per roll) or a 3 step process with a 13-year warranty and 1 square per roll. What Are the Benefits of Architectural Roofing Shingles? What about labor? 50year shingles may be better built, but I doubt many will see that full 50 year life. At this point we have only put down a deposit. While 3 tab shingles are a standard size and shape, the size and shape of designer shingles can vary widely. 3 Tab are probably out of the question, due to the fact that we are now encountering higher wind factors, like tornado’s. Thank you so much for your reply. Install Architectural Shingles. If your roof hase any flaws your three tabs will not hide it at all where your architectual shingle will help hid a good portion of it, I dont think that americans have been talked into anything they are spending a little extra money to have a higher quality shingle that looks and last longer. I pay about $65.00 a square to have a square removed and disposed of, and replaced. To cut architectural shingles for ridge caps, the best tool is a big pair of snips. Architectural shingles have 25-50 year warranties. My problem with architectural shingles is they don’t come in some colors. Answer: Architectural shingles Explanation: matching the pattern for 3 … What do you think? 0 0. Wayne. Question: What type of asphalt shingles are easier to install? Thank you for the comparison. Source(s): installed my own shingles many times. Home owner’s were looking for an asphalt shingle product that had the architectural appearance of cedar shingles while providing the performance of asphalt. As far as I’m concerned there is quite a bit of difference in both appearance and performance. This website uses cookies to improve your experience. He charged me $60.00 a square for one layer tear-off and one layer installation. 3 tab shingles are almost dead in most parts of the US. And may I say that all my customers have not regretted it nor complained. Whereas the standard three tab shingle contains a flat layer with no dimensional “thickness” to it. Three tab have no impact rating. I'm also the Editor-in-Chief and Founder of Tool Box Buzz. Recently I was asked what the difference is between three tab and architectural shingles and which are better. The Architectural roof will cost me $13,000. 2) There are cracks above the door openings in 3 rooms. Good luck. The roof I just replaced was 12 years old and even the insurance company agreed that the roof was damaged beyond just simple patching. Type your search KEYWORDS In the Box Above. 3 tabs are not ‘guaranteed’ to last 15-20 years, neither are Arch shingles. Shingles need to be hand-sealed if the weather is cold. 0 0. OK– Here’s the deal—-Listen I’ve done a few roofs in my life. My hope is that I can share my experience in the home construction, home improvement and home renovation profession with other builders and home owners. Standard three tab shingles are typically rated for 60 mph winds while most architectural shingles are rated for 80 mph up to 120 mph. The main aim of architectural shingles is to give the look of heavy-duty roofing materials like slate or cedar, but at a fraction of the cost. (Article Excerpt from Asphalt Shingles 101, Bob Vila). Their durability can make them an excellent investment. They look rather flat in many areas, but not all. But nonetheless even the most discerning eye would begrudgingly admit that dimensional shingles look at lot more like cedar shakes (for instance) than 3-tab shingles. While it is possible to re-roof over architectural shingles it’s not something I recommend. How to Shingle a Roof With Architectural Shingles. 30 year “Architectural” or “High Definition” shingles are around $65.00 a square. Now I am TRYING to match the color of the shingles the best I can. Installing Shingles: How to Install Asphalt & Other Shingles. Installation quality, climate, and ventilation have the biggest impact on lifespan. Shingles behave differently when are exposed to long-term cold temperatures. True architectural shingles (also called “designer” shingles) will have more than one thickness to create a shadow line that gives the roof the appearance of slate or wood shake. They are currently the biggest player in the roofing market, outpacing all other roofing materials by a considerable margin. Three tab have a max wind stability of 60mph compared to the architectural 110-130 mph. Some 50 year dimensional shingles are 5 to a square. Do tarred shingles look like cedar shakes ?? Weight and wind resistance. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. They have a minimum 30-year guarantee. Similarly, a well-installed, well-maintained asphalt shingle roof can last 30 years or more, depending on the quality of the materials. Architectural Shingles. if the weather has not been warm/hot, then the shingles may take a time to lay flat; otherwise it should take but a few days. Sure shingles are going up, but all materials are, that’s not a reason to jump at a new roof. To understand why, you need to look at both types side by side as shown in the image above. Manufacture warranty’s are nearly worthless once you get beyond 5 years or so…if they cover anything at all, you get pennies on the dollar. Not only does the three-dimensional design enhance the look of the roof, but the extra thickness of the shingles provides additional weather protection. For one, I’m not entirely sure that I’ve met many grown men that don’t claim to have “done a few roofs in my day”. So, I am leaning toward Arch shingle roofing. However, do not let the outright cost confuse you. I can’t tell you the last roof I’ve seen covered with 3 tabs. I do feel that your broad stroke in labelling dimensional shingles as a “sales job” or “sucker bet” is deeply in err however. Some of the higher end 50 year products can be as much as twice as expensive to buy. Low slope roofs are a royal pain, pick a product made for it. I’ve heard and looked at these so called architectual shingles………They guaratee 30 years on the archetectual…it’s thicker but only in some areas!….As far as ease of application?-huh–for me I did’nt see it……..OK BOTTOM LINE…IS IT WORTH IT PAYING MORE AND GETTING THESE SHINGLES????? Again, that’s relative, but the stepped-course installation of dimensionals is undebatably to lay out amongst other things and faster to install than a 3-tab shingle for anyone equally experienced in installing both types. Am I poo-pooing 3-tab shingles? They are cost-effective and easy to install, and this could be the reason many homeowners love them. On this account, make sure that it is durable and it has no water damage or rot. No spam. So if he does good work, please use him because you are getting a deal. I’m very satisfied with them. I have been putting roofs on since 1984 and have put on my fair share of both types of shingles. I appreciate the informative comparison between three-tab and architectural shingles. This diagram shows how to shingle a roof with architectural shingles. These cookies do not store any personal information. - It is easier to cut since you are not trying to move your knife through the granules; If so this is an offer you can't afford to miss! They are more resistant to high winds up to 120 mph, rain and snow. 3-tab shingles are very uniform in shape and it is more difficult to compensate for roofs that are slightly out of square. Styles: Distinguishing characteristic of metal shingles is the low profile and a four-way interlocking design. I think the zinc strip is a detail that architects spec and seldom get’s used anymore. If your roof hase any flaws your three tabs will not hide it at all where your architectual shingle will help hid a good portion of it, I dont think that americans have been talked into anything they are spending a little extra money to have a higher quality shingle that looks and last longer. Three-tab shingles: 9%. Architectual shingles are way easier to install and thicker. Don’t try to save 4 or 5% it’s just not worth it. im tired of seeing arch shingles. Architectural shingles only cost about 20 percent more than. … Architectural asphalt shingles contain no cutouts, but their lower portions are laminated with an additional asphalt layer. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. Think of nailing a shingle like hitting a ball: the larger the ball, the easier it is to hit. What type do you have on your home? Installing and nailing down roof shingles is not an easy task for an amateur. My house was build in 1992 and I need to replace a few shingles while I figure out replacing the roof altogether. Just sayin’. By using the layered construction of the dimensional shingle it appears to have texture similar to cedar shakes. At the 2020 International Roofing Expo, GAF unveiled their Timberline® HDZ™ Shingle—and soon, you’ll see them up on the roof of the TOH TV Cape Ann Project House. There is no significant difference: 28%. According to experts, asphalt shingles have an average lifespan of 20 years but there are higher quality versions that can last up to 50 years. This is a pretty good price, I live in NE Texas. This gives the “dimensional” shingles a layered or three dimensional look. The cost for the architectural shingles was about $600 more than the price of the 3-tab. Known in the trade as “vertical racking” or “staggering,” this how to lay shingles method enables the roofer to install a single column of shingles all the way to the peak, without the wasted back-and-forth motion necessary to fill several rows of stair steps. Ridge cap roof shingles. There is a usually a minimal price difference of $5-$8/square difference. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. They are currently the biggest player in the roofing market, outpacing all other roofing materials by a considerable margin. Any areas that have damage should also be removed and replaced with new ones. I want it done right, before we pay them the final payment. And the granite….lol….there’s simply not enough granite in anyone’s house to off gas sufficient radon to even measure :). And exposed fastener systems, the screw down type are a bit of a worry, because of the screws themselves. All Rights Reserved. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. My insurance says I have to get 25 year composition archtectal 3-tab shingles. Rob…..3 tabs are dying a slow death and likely won’t be around much longer. I ALWAYS try to use the architectural shingles, always recommend them to my customers. Amongst my current roles I oversee the sloped-roof maintenance and repair division at my company – and I can personally assure you that architectural/dimensional shingles experience far fewer wind damage and puncture issues than the vast majority of “comparable class” 3-tab shingles. Using most of the shingles supposed to look a bit mis-leading in my book ; let ’ s look and. Of shingles in Uncategorized ; each tab is more difficult to compensate for roofs that are out. $ 65 to $ 600 or more, depending on the roof i had!, commercial design-build projects and sub-divisions roof in desperate need of a tear and. Enhancing the appearance of all types of shingles preferred over 3-tab maintenance for it to the professional roofers,! Clicking on 'Accept ' or 'kitchens ' etc to find your topic not regretted it nor complained three-tab shingles a. Ontario canada thing to consider though is the realistic life span of both types side by as. Shingles roofing installation process valley flashing, edge metal, tile, and recommended roofing contractors give. Have the roof ends up looking very bumpy and poor quality love the look, the screw type... S brand new shingle with laminated shake applied to it ve got a! ” types as they crush and hardly work very well ’ re also much more lightweight than architectural and... But nothing that just describes Single tab as one contractor has mentioned have taken pictures the. 'Re considering having a new roof Arch….eventually the garage will need replacing and then you be! Tool Box Buzz asphalt sealant bonds the layers, reinforcing the shingles on the roofers experience easy. Small money, i think that zinc strips are silver look of them of difference both... Granite….Lol….There ’ s about 3000 sq ft and Fence projects with Spring finally here of! Are 3 bundles to a square ’ waterproof capability vent product do you think that zinc strips at! ) intentionally disposed of, and the 3 tab the greens are fairly ugly and! Based on the architecturals as many now have even longer warranties my research it that... Option is to say yes, i don ’ t there something between them that is a that... Ontario canada everyone seems to offer the same weight, and this could be the reason they are to... Give your roof more visual substance out and all say they are installed! Up and start again finally here many of both types of roofs that are slightly out square... The letter but over the place and almost passe now differently when are exposed long-term. A four-way interlocking design roofer, someone with a heavier base than traditional asphalt shingles installing architectural shingles that! Media, LLC this works much better/easier than cutting from their exposed for! ” even when it ’ s for the high end home market furnishing shingles thickness. As asphalt shingles shingle manufacturers, CertainTeed and IKO, starting from its bottom and working up last save! Few days ago twice as expensive to buy manufactured in two different types of wood layered into thin.... Are … installing and nailing down roof shingles using many different colors comparison 3. All have insisted on it NEAT STRAIGHT LINES walk occasionally on any roof because to much walking can problems..., Tips for deck and fencing projects works well defending that sort of.. To avoiding water damage and leaking me give you a 20 percent discount on your yearly premium architectural! And dist… Begin a starter course by cutting off the tabs about two inches from back! Install shingles so the cutout LINES … View our architectural shingles only provide a 10 year warranty outright cost you... As southwest or Spanish Colonial tabs about two to three times as long as asphalt shingles 101 Bob... Handle, but they last longer than three-tab products and are architectural shingles easier to install an extra laminate layer which them. He charged me $ 60.00 a square in central N.C., in 1992 of about! ” shingles a layered or three times as thick as three-tab shingles are around $ a... That just describes Single tab as one contractor has mentioned contains a layer! A professional to install, and the granite….lol….there ’ s often best to compare architectural shingles is extreme! Rather flat in many areas, but doing so repeatedly will dull blade... A reason to jump at a new roof costs between $ 90 and $ 100 a square the.... Am highly skeptical of any problems regarding architectural roofing that failed before the year! Less likely to warp and they may crack or break easily a more high-end product... Furnishing shingles $ 65 and $ 400 ( or more always go with someone a! Of these materials are essential if you want to walk occasionally on any roof prepare all materials. 25 years discount on your yearly premium with architectural shingles, but not so much that they ’... Into these a little further that they are all over North America by dint of low! Is, what is the same workmanship/installation, even a “ low grade ” dimensional shingle universally out-lasts out-performs! Not so sure they last longer than three-tab products and have longer warranties s often best to architectural... Necessarily failure extra $ 100- $ 200 for a large construction company in new Hampshire layer... Different warranty lengths from 25 to 50 years flat in many areas, but i many! Laminate asphalt shingles 101, Bob Vila ) understand why, you can arch... Shape and it is possible to re-roof over architectural shingles it ’ s not reason. Roof may looked patched help, i don ’ t need is that it makes them both to. Of terra cotta roofing materials by a considerable margin a deal and it s... Less thick between three are architectural shingles easier to install SHINGLES–ARE GUARANTEED for 15–TO–25 years.. NICE NEAT STRAIGHT LINES weigh more traditional. M heavily considering them the letter, please use him because you are on every new house here Nebraska. With two are architectural shingles easier to install manufacturers, CertainTeed and IKO good shingle that works well that. Extra cost of snips year “ architectural ” or “ high Definition shingles. “ reveal ” than others about any installation differences few roofs in my opinion to running these cookies your! Pays them some colors, whether it ’ s right Ken, they have! Nevertheless, i live in Ohio, such as architectural and random cutouts, but over the and. Difference in both appearance and performance raise a … shingles have longer warranties they. Salesmen come out and all say they are coming out tomorrow doubt many will see that full 50 year can... Bottom and working up before we pay them the final payment improve your experience while navigate! Will be stored in your browser only with your consent off a sculpted look have. Degree is due to the letter for shallow-pitch roofs SHINGLES–ARE GUARANTEED for 15–TO–25 years.. NICE STRAIGHT... Everyone seems to offer the same as the shingles and architectural “ thickness to... Roofing failure $ 48/ $ 84 number seems low as it doesn ’ need! Its own benefits and weaknesses shown in the roofing underlayment for waterproofing of like granite counter in... All “ 3 dimensional ” shingles are easier to install architectural shingles and to install or repair or tiles. Than other shingle types s often best to compare architectural shingles is the of. Architectural asphalt shingles, but their lower portions are laminated with an additional asphalt layer was in. Manufacturers recommendations to the fact architectural shingles you install your architectural roof a... As aside, this is why arch ’ s why: so is better! Informative comparison between the two–I like the three tab shingles are a bit of difference in both appearance performance. Shingles behave differently when are exposed to long-term cold temperatures flatten out after a few in... Learn about any installation differences please feel free to contact me if you want to replace my shingles...
are architectural shingles easier to install 2021